COLORADO: Study shows air emissions near fracking sites may impact health
They contain hydrocarbons including benzene
Contact: David Kelly
david.kelly@ucdenver.edu
303-315-6374
University of Colorado Denver
AURORA, Colo. -- In a new study,
researchers from the Colorado School of Public Health have shown that air
pollution caused by hydraulic fracturing or fracking may contribute to acute
and chronic health problems for those living near natural gas drilling sites.
"Our data show that it is
important to include air pollution in the national dialogue on natural gas
development that has focused largely on water exposures to hydraulic
fracturing," said Lisa McKenzie, Ph.D., MPH, lead author of the study and
research associate at the Colorado School of Public Health.
The study will be published in an upcoming
edition of Science of the Total Environment.
The report, based on three years of
monitoring, found a number of potentially toxic petroleum hydrocarbons in the
air near the wells including benzene, ethylbenzene, toluene and xylene. Benzene
has been identified by the Environmental Protection Agency as a known
carcinogen. Other chemicals included heptane, octane and diethylbenzene but
information on their toxicity is limited.
"Our results show that the
non-cancer health impacts from air emissions due to natural gas development is
greater for residents living closer to wells," the report said. "The
greatest health impact corresponds to the relatively short-term, but high
emission, well completion period."
That's due to exposure to
trimethylbenzenes, aliaphatic hydrocarbons, and xylenes, all of which have
neurological and/or respiratory effects, the study said. Those effects could
include eye irritation, headaches, sore throat and difficulty breathing.
"We also calculated higher
cancer risks for residents living nearer to the wells as compared to those
residing further [away]," the report said. "Benzene is the major
contributor to lifetime excess cancer risk from both scenarios."
The report, which looked at those
living about a half-mile from the wells, comes in response to the rapid
expansion of natural gas development in rural Garfield County, in western
Colorado.
Typically, wells are developed in
stages that include drilling followed by hydraulic fracturing , the high
powered injection of water and chemicals into the drilled area to release the
gas. After that, there is flowback or the return of fracking and geologic
fluids, hydrocarbons and natural gas to the surface. The gas is then collected
and sold.
Garfield County asked the Colorado
School of Public Health to assess the potential health impacts of these wells
on the community of Battlement Mesa with a population of about 5,000.
McKenzie analyzed ambient air sample
data collected from monitoring stations by the Garfield County Department of
Public Health and Olsson Associates Inc. She used standard EPA methodology to
estimate non-cancer health impacts and excess lifetime cancer risks for
hydrocarbon exposure.
McKenzie noted that EPA standards
are designed to be public health proactive and may overestimate risks.
"However, there wasn't data
available on all the chemicals emitted during the well development
process," she said. "If there had been, then it is entirely possible
the risks would have been underestimated."
The report concludes that health
risks are greater for people living closest to wells and urges a reduction in
those air emissions.
McKenzie said future studies are
warranted and should include collection of area, residential and personal
exposure data where wells are operating. Additional studies, she said, should
also examine the toxicity of other hydrocarbons associated with natural gas
development.
###
The study is entitled "Human
Health Risk Assessment of Air Emissions from Development of Unconventional
Natural Gas Resources." It was accepted for publication in March by
Elsevier Science Ireland Ltd.
About the Colorado School of Public
Health
The Colorado School of Public Health
is the first and only accredited school of public health in the Rocky Mountain
Region, attracting top tier faculty and students from across the country, and
providing a vital contribution towards ensuring our region's health and
well-being. Collaboratively formed by the University of Colorado Denver,
Colorado State University, and the University of Northern Colorado, the
Colorado School of Public Health provides training, innovative research and
community service to actively address public health issues, including chronic
disease, access to health care, environmental threats, emerging infectious
diseases, and costly injuries. |